St. Matthew's Lutheran Church, Oconomowoc, Wisconsin: The Years of Controversy - 1922-1932

Abstract

This essay explores the formative decade of St. Matthew’s Lutheran Church in Oconomowoc, Wisconsin, from its founding in 1922 through a period of theological and institutional controversy ending in 1932. The congregation emerged from a schism with St. Paul’s Lutheran Church and became entangled in the Protestant Conference movement, which challenged the Wisconsin Synod’s handling of doctrinal disputes. Central to the conflict was Pastor W. P. Hass, whose suspension and continued influence divided the congregation. Drawing on congregational minutes, correspondence, and synodical records, the essay traces legal battles, internal dissent, and eventual reconciliation. In 1932, the congregation rejoined the Wisconsin Synod and called Rev. Norbert Paustian as pastor, marking a new chapter of unity and growth. The study offers insight into the dynamics of church governance, doctrinal fidelity, and the resilience of a faith community navigating ecclesiastical strife.

Abstract prepared by Microsoft Copilot (GPT-4), based on the original essay by Brian Adams.